Your SIP During Market Corrections: A Perspective from Your Advisor
As your trusted financial advisor, I’ve observed market cycles, each presenting unique challenges and opportunities. The current correction, initiated in September 2024, is no exception. It’s a moment that tests our resolve and underscores the importance of a well-defined, long-term investment strategy. I understand the anxieties and questions many of you are grappling with: “Should I pause my SIP?” “Is it time to liquidate my holdings?”
These are valid concerns, and I’m here to provide clarity and guidance, grounded in both experience and data.
The Emotional Rollercoaster of Investing: A Human Element
Let’s acknowledge the human element in investing. It’s not just about numbers; it’s about emotions. The surge from March 2023 to September 2024 generated a wave of optimism, with many investors eagerly participating in the market’s upward trajectory. However, the subsequent downturn has triggered a stark shift in sentiment, often leading to impulsive decisions driven by fear. This emotional pendulum swing is a natural human response. We are wired to seek immediate gratification and avoid pain. During bull markets, the constant positive feedback loop reinforces our belief in the market’s invincibility. Conversely, during corrections, the sight of red on our portfolio statements can be deeply unsettling.
The Fundamental Principle: Rupee-Cost Averaging and Its Practical Application
It’s crucial to revisit the core principle that underpins our SIP strategy: rupee-cost averaging. This approach is designed to mitigate the impact of market volatility by investing a fixed sum at regular intervals. When markets are high, your investment buys fewer units; when they are low, it buys more. This inherently averages out your purchase price over time, reducing the risk of timing the market.
However, the psychological challenge lies in maintaining discipline during downturns. The allure of locking in gains during bull markets and the fear of further losses during corrections can tempt us to deviate from our long-term strategy.
Illustrative Case Studies: Lessons from the Past, Data-Driven Insights
To illustrate the power of disciplined investing, let’s examine the experiences of three hypothetical investors during the period from May 2014 to February 2025. We’ll use actual fund performance data to provide concrete insights.
Scenario:
- Fund: ICICI Pru Bluechip Fund Regular Growth
- Investment: ₹30,000 per month
- Investment Date: 3rd of each month
Investor Profiles:
- Mr. A: Stopped investing after a market peak in March 2015.
- Mr. B: Considered stopping after two years, seeing minimal returns in April 2016.
- Mr. C: Continued investing consistently through February 2025.
Amount invest till 03 March 2015 | Value of investment 03 March 2015 | XIRR 03 March 2015 | Amount invest till 04 April 2016 | Value of investment 04 April 2016 | XIRR 04 April 2016 | Amount invest till 28 February 2025 | Value of investment 28 February 2025 | XIRR 28 February 2025 | |
Mr A | ₹330,000.00 | ₹380,676.25 | 40.15 | ₹330,000.00 | ₹339,237.09 | 1.85 | ₹330,000.00 | ₹1,180,770.67 | 13.05 |
Mr B | ₹330,000.00 | ₹380,676.25 | 40.15 | ₹720,000.00 | ₹722,348.10 | 0.34 | ₹720,000.00 | ₹2,514,251.72 | 13.50 |
Mr C | ₹330,000.00 | ₹380,676.25 | 40.15 | ₹720,000.00 | ₹722,348.10 | 0.34 | ₹3,900,000.00 | ₹9,250,544.68 | 15.18 |
Analysis
Let’s look at each investor’s journey.
- Mr. A: By March 3, 2015, Mr. A had invested ₹330,000. His investment value was ₹380,676.25, with an XIRR of 40.15%. However, he stopped investing at this point. By February 28, 2025, his final investment value was ₹1,180,770.67, with an XIRR of 13.05%.
- Mr. B: Like Mr. A, Mr. B’s investment by March 3, 2015, was ₹330,000, with a value of ₹380,676.25 and an XIRR of 40.15%. By April 4, 2016, after two years, his invested amount was ₹720,000, and his investment value was ₹722,348.10, with an XIRR of only 0.34%. He considered stopping then. However, by February 28, 2025, his investment value was ₹2,514,251.72, with an XIRR of 13.50%.
- Mr. C: Mr. C also started with the same figures as Mr. A and B, but he continued investing. By April 4, 2016, he was in the same position as Mr. B, with an invested amount of ₹720,000, a value of ₹722,348.10, and an XIRR of 0.34%. However, by February 28, 2025, with a total invested amount of ₹3,900,000, his investment value was ₹9,250,544.68, with an XIRR of 15.18%.
Detailed Observations:
- Mr. A achieved a high initial XIRR but missed substantial long-term growth by stopping his SIP. If he had withdrawn his money at the 40.15% XIRR, he would have only made roughly 50,000 rupees.
- Mr. B faced a challenging period with minimal returns after two years, nearly halting his SIP. However, by staying invested, he achieved a respectable long-term return.
- Mr. C demonstrated the power of consistent investing, achieving the highest returns and wealth accumulation. He remained invested through market fluctuations.
Key Insights and Takeaways from the Data:
- Long-Term Growth Wins: Mr. C’s results highlight the benefits of staying invested.
- Avoid Emotional Decisions: Mr. A and Mr. B’s experiences show the dangers of reacting to short-term market changes.
- The Power of Averaging: Market corrections allow for buying more units at lower prices.
- Wealth Creation is a Marathon: Longer investment periods yield better results.
Navigating the Current Correction: A Practical, Data-Informed Approach
In light of the current market correction, I urge you to adopt a proactive and disciplined approach, informed by the data we’ve reviewed.
- Portfolio Review: Ensure your asset allocation aligns with your risk tolerance and long-term goals.
- Continue Your SIP: Maintain your regular investments to capitalise on rupee-cost averaging.
- Resist Market Timing: As the data shows, consistent investing outperforms attempts to time the market.
- Stay Informed, Not Overwhelmed: Filter out market noise and focus on your long-term strategy.
- Consult Your Advisor: Let’s discuss your concerns and ensure your portfolio remains aligned with your evolving needs.
The Indispensable Role of a Trusted Advisor
As your advisor, my primary responsibility is to guide you through market cycles, providing data-driven insights and emotional support. I understand the challenges of investing, and I’m here to help you make informed decisions that align with your financial goals.
Let’s schedule a time to discuss your specific concerns and refine your plan. By working together, we can navigate this market correction and ensure your portfolio remains aligned with your long-term goals. Please reach out to me to schedule a consultation.